Patek's "Mona Lisa Smile"

Apr 03, 2013,03:49 AM
 

Leonardo da Vinci’s  “Mona Lisa” is probably the most famous painting in the world. Most experts would say that, technically, it is not Leonardo’s finest work. Indeed, most experts would suggest that other artists have produced many works of a finer quality. Yet, if ever the Mona Lisa was put up for sale, it would almost certainly blast through prevailing world records. Further, if you asked art experts what they felt to be the world’s most famous painting, then almost certainly the Mona Lisa would feature prominently. And what has this got to do with horology?

 

Well, I would argue it is all about enigma. Mona Lisa’s smile. Scientists have attempted to understand why this specific painting has so captured the world’s imagination. And the answer is to do with that smile (dial). One minute Mona appears radiant and warm, the next minute she appears serious and sardonic. Scientists now claim to understand why her smile is so enigmatic. Her mood changes according to which signals our eyes receive first. The scientists believe Mona Lisa's smile depends on how the cells in our retinas receive the image and, crucially, what particular channel the image gets transmitted through to the brain.

 

“Sometimes one channel wins over the other, and you see the smile, sometimes others take over and you do not see the smile,” said Dr Luis Martinez Otero, a neuroscientist at Institute of Neuroscience in Alicante, Spain, who conducted the study. There almost seems to be a random element in how any specific individual interprets the painting. What science tells us is that different cells in the eye pick up different colours, backgrounds and foregrounds and contrasts. Certain types of image lend themselves more readily to varying interpretation. In other words, the enigmatic part of the Mona Lisa is a reflection of the fact that her “mood” appears transient.

 

Just like the dial on the 5070P!!

 

(Ok, Art…circuitous I know…..but the fact that Mona Lisa’s “smile” also rhymes with 5070P’s dial made it irresistible)

 

There have been a few posts on the 5070P in recent weeks and I certainly responded with a scan of my version. And I remarked to myself how badly I had captured the watch. In reality, most owners of the 5070P will know how impossible it is to capture the true enigmatic nature of the dial. I now know why. In reality, the dial is never one thing. Sometimes it catches this very dark, almost matt black persona. Other times it has this cheery and happy almost glossy blue appearance. Sometimes its numerals just leap out in a most distinct manner, and other times they are almost camouflaged. It is so hard to capture the personality well.

 

Well, with the sun out (and with my son home to help), I thought I would have a go at capturing some of the 5070P’s enigmatic personality. Apologies in advance for the fact that my watch case has more than a few scratches and blemishes. It gets a lot of time on…Also, I won’t use photoshop at all to alter the images.


Let's start with some customary wristshots.....

Hint of blue.....matt..... not so much life here....but see how the numerals jump out

Hint of blue.....matt..... not so much life here....but see how the numerals jump out


Slightly more hints of blue....numerals in hiding

Slightly more hints of blue....numerals in hiding


Dial almost had hints of grey now

Dial almost had hints of grey now


But wow....the sun catching the subdial...creates a new contrast

But wow....the sun catching the subdial...creates a new contrast


Now to take some shots inside and away from the sun.  



Just love that shadow....dial appears so black in some light

Just love that shadow....dial appears so black in some light


Just a small twist to the left...and bang it catches that outside light!

Just a small twist to the left...and bang it catches that outside light!


But catch that light to full-on and we get yet another variant of the dial...

But catch that light to full-on and we get yet another variant of the dial...

Have i managed to capture its enigmatic "smile"? Well, here are some more attempts....

In sunlight again....harsh ...dark ....almost black again.... but sub-dials flashing with life

In sunlight again....harsh ...dark ....almost black again.... but sub-dials flashing with life

Jet black....killer mode

Jet black....killer mode


Beautiful...subtle blue....almost gilty.....just stunning

Beautiful...subtle blue....almost gilty.....just stunning


Well, I will leave with just one last wristshot. 

Just awesome

Just awesome



What makes this watch so stunning? Well, in my view it has the Mona Lisa effect. It has the Mona Lisa Dial! It can change from one second to another...and does so. Its sub-dials also have the same effect. I had not realised this until today! But the sub-dials act almost independently to the rest of the dial...taking on light in a varying manner that provides yet more different permutations for interpretation.

So, have I captured the enigmatic nature of the dial? The answer is a certain...No. There is a film called "Big Fish". In the film, there is a great line....

"There are some fish that cannot be caught. It's not that they're faster or stronger than other fish. They're just touched by something extra. Call it luck. Call it grace."

The 5070P is touched by "something extra". 


More posts: 5070complications

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Agreed. The dial of the 5070 is really something.

 
 By: amanico : April 3rd, 2013-04:01
It is true on the G , it is ven more true on the P. The finish of the dial doesn't work when the light is too strong. It will look harsh. A mild light will make it look better, IMO. I got the same conclusion when playing with a P for some hours. Here are ...  
login to reply

Poor attempts :)

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : April 3rd, 2013-04:30
I like your modesty when blue is in question ;) Best D
login to reply

Much better

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : April 3rd, 2013-06:14
than first picture? What you wanna have us cardiac arrest?? Best my friend D
login to reply

I will try... ;) [nt]

 
 By: amanico : April 3rd, 2013-23:02
login to reply

Ah Baron, I really like your way of putting things together....

 
 By: Sandgroper : April 3rd, 2013-04:26
your are like a magician! Yes, the 5070P has a very nice dial, I am not denying it, however, the beautiful contrast that one can observe and cherish with this dial can also be observed and cherished when it comes to other Brands, the Datograph and others ... 
login to reply

Hey Francois

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : April 3rd, 2013-05:33
Thanks for that. For sure there are other dials that have this almost transient nature. The Lange is certainly one that I would love to have on the wrist for a trial! Alas, I have not yet. With the 5070P, I think one of the things that I didn't mention is... 
login to reply

Blue because of the Anti Reflect Coating, on the Dato, my friend;

 
 By: amanico : April 3rd, 2013-05:55
The dial is deep black, but the ARC gives a trciky aspect to the dial. Best, Nicolas
login to reply

Is that so? Didn't know, so this is a bad example.....

 
 By: Sandgroper : April 3rd, 2013-16:50
what about the Septantieme then, I don't think it has an ARC and the dial really dances under different lights! Cheers, Francois
login to reply

Different case. The 70eme has a ruthenium guilloché dial which loves to play with light.

 
 By: amanico : April 3rd, 2013-23:02
And I would say that the light loves to play with the Septantieme Dial, too... Best, Nicolas
login to reply

Ok! then I shut up:) [nt]

 
 By: Sandgroper : April 3rd, 2013-23:16
login to reply

true true true...

 
 By: Fricks : April 3rd, 2013-04:27
... in french they call it this "je ne sais quoi". Something you cannot put your finger on. Some call it magic or Voodoo :) , other call it charm. Some don't even know what to call it, but they express it with a smile on their face. I think you really cau... 
login to reply

Your post made me smile :)

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : April 3rd, 2013-04:29
Wonderfully put together For sure this reference will in future be pinnacle for PP aficionados Thank you for nice pictures Best Damjan
login to reply

The Perfect Blue.

 
 By: Iceman : April 3rd, 2013-04:47
Great post Baron and fantastic photos., totally agree with u this blue is nothing short of perfect ( if there is such a thing as perfect).. I will let the picture do all the talking! My favourite wrist shoot! ...  
login to reply

Gorgeous pics !

 
 By: dirost : April 3rd, 2013-15:28
I don't know if the 5070P is as sexy as Mona Lisa's smile, but it is cheaper anyway ;-) Seriously, a watch with a very particular beauty. Thanks for sharing.
login to reply

The blue dial on 5070P is the most attractive one.

 
 By: Grisar : April 3rd, 2013-06:32
Among 5110P, 5100G, 5712A and 5070P, I admit that the dial of 5070P is the most attractive one. Incredible. In fact, all four different variants of 5070 have their own personalities, all very beautiful. Great job done by PP.
login to reply

Fabulous...!

 
 By: bsodmike : April 3rd, 2013-07:06
Thanks for sharing that Baron, you've captured its emotions rather well.
login to reply

Stunning shots!

 
 By: bulliondesk : April 3rd, 2013-07:56
Great post!
login to reply

Capturing some magic

 
 By: Le Monde Edmond : April 3rd, 2013-10:04
You certainly have captured my imagination and appeal to this watch. Up untill your pictures - I thought only Rolex dials were able to catch the light so well. This post proves that Patek is just as able. Very enjoyable post- thank you for the effort! Bes... 
login to reply

and just for some fun......

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : April 3rd, 2013-11:01
up close and personal ...  
login to reply

It is certainly a beautiful thing!! Cheers, [nt]

 
 By: SteelerFan1965 : April 3rd, 2013-11:19
login to reply

Very well put!

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : April 3rd, 2013-13:33
I really like your comparision with Mona Lisa, my friend! Another way to put it is like I use to compare the Reverso with a Zen garden. For each step something conceal itself and something else reveals itself to the eye...... It is a beautiful dial on thi... 
login to reply

Truly lovely...

 
 By: blackrainbow : April 3rd, 2013-18:10
Truly lovely - one of the things I love is not only its beauty but also how wearable it is for almost any occasion or style Thank you for the pics
login to reply

Nicely taken photos, Baron............

 
 By: Topcat30093 : April 7th, 2013-00:42
Of a classic Patek. Please wear it more often if this is the effect that it has on our weather :)
login to reply

Great post, that's why this watch is so magical !

 
 By: cisco : April 8th, 2013-07:22
Someone finally catches it, Thank you Baron ! Francois
login to reply

it has been said...

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : April 8th, 2013-11:25
.....that my photography can make Claudia Schiffer look ugly..... but I am happy with these 5070P shots!!
login to reply

I missed this topic!!!

 
 By: gensiulia : April 27th, 2013-09:07
Just amazing watch! i love this classic pieces without luminous markers. means a lot to me. ciao, chris
login to reply

that is maybe true, Chris....

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : April 27th, 2013-09:21
....but i am loving that kissing 4!!
login to reply

Be strong, Joe...

 
 By: gensiulia : April 27th, 2013-11:11
...Monday is around the corner ;)
login to reply

actually...Monday will bring something somewhat new! [nt]

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : April 27th, 2013-11:16
login to reply

even better! I hope to see some new masterpiece! [nt]

 
 By: gensiulia : April 27th, 2013-11:29
login to reply

Compliments

 
 By: Merke : April 27th, 2013-12:19
Well, you say you're absolutely right, we are talking about the 5070P trial of great charm ..... a watch with a unique beauty!
login to reply

worn a lot

 
 By: watch-er : April 29th, 2013-13:30
That watch has been worn a lot and the nice patina it has taken on adds to its character.
login to reply

Great reference post Joe

 
 By: Mark in Paris : November 29th, 2015-08:57
It deserves a little up for sure. One thing I would add: the light available in retailers (spots) are not the kind of light that help seeing the true beauty of dials. I saw the 5070P's dial only once in a second-hand shop and the experience was far from p... 
login to reply