I agree that

Jun 12, 2008,23:43 PM
 

the 5098 is overpriced for what it is. However, I don't think it can be compared with the 5124 as it has a completely different look.
To me, the 5124 is straight forward and rather plain looking, like so many other watches of the same ilk. The 5098P is a stunningly beautiful watch which  has a dial like no other I have seen. Still overpriced . I will look forward to getting a pre-owned one later on.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

considering a 5098P. i like the watch. but with the price increase this year, and.........

 
 By: a.ler : June 4th, 2008-22:06
comparing other watches of the price range, can i still justify the purchase? any opinions?

The 5098 was once on my wish list,but when I saw

 
 By: happyguy1688 : June 5th, 2008-10:19
the 5124G, I just jump to it. IMHO, 5124G has the following pros over 5098: 1. price is only 1/2; 2. it has small second hand 3 the case back is curve instead of flat like the 5098 and is much more elegant 4.the original gondolo used round instead of form... 

Agree with you

 
 By: amanico : June 5th, 2008-11:40

I agree that

 
 By: johnsinger56 : June 12th, 2008-23:43
the 5098 is overpriced for what it is. However, I don't think it can be compared with the 5124 as it has a completely different look. To me, the 5124 is straight forward and rather plain looking, like so many other watches of the same ilk. The 5098P is a ... 

as beautiful as 5098 is

 
 By: WatchFan1 : June 5th, 2008-12:44
I also have a hard time to justify the price that c an afford annual calendar. On top of it - introduction of 5124G just makes it an easy choice for me