I am THEE unlucky one!!!

Jun 02, 2009,18:26 PM
 


First I will "copy/paste" of what happened to me since last september, which I posted before.
Post #1 Dated November 2008
"I truly put a lot of thought before posting the following. But I think I should share.

Few weeks ago, I posted a message talking about my 5960 which stopped all of a sudden and it has been almost 2 months that it is still being fixed.
At the end of the day it is watch and even though it might be rare, "sh*t happens". I posted my message because the wait is too long.

Two weeks ago, I had my *0th birthday and I am proud to say, my wife got me a 5980, which I wanted to have. At the very same night, my father showed me the unfortunate.
He pulled out his 5101, which is few months old, to wear it. He noticed that something looked really different. He looked again, he couldn't tell the time.
It was the minute indicator. It was not in its place. The indicator was totally unscrewed from the center. Any angle you turn the watch the indicator was moving and was free from the center.

This is completely unacceptable. This is not a complicated movement problem, this is a simple problem! I am staggered such quality problem happening with a PP, nevertheless with a Grand Complication PP.
I am very loyal to PP and it is by far my number one choice.
But I think it is time for PP management to turn their big magnifying loops on their QC."

Post #2 Dated March 2009
"Few weeks ago, I was taking my watch off. I pulled it out of my wrist and holding it with my right hand.
All of a sudden it slipped my hand and fell on the floor(hardwood). The height was about 32 inches(81 cm).
I saw the watch falling face angled about 45 degrees. It seemed like, the platinum frame was going to take the first hit.
The same second, I heard "POOOFFF".
There were only few tiny pieces are left of the crystal on the floor and the rest was a dust.
There was no crystal left on the watch.

The next day I took back to the AD. First, I didn't tell what happened; they couldn't either.
Nothing happened to the dial TG, except crystal dust which needs to be cleaned but they might have to open everything to make sure nothing
slipped inside the movement.

Isn't amazing, a watch like that falls from 80cm and the crystal blows away."

Last Update:

2 weeks ago my AD called and said the 5960 is ready. I go to pick it up.
He opens the sealed bag. The crystal is replaced, but the dial. The dial is full of scratches.
the scratches are so clear, you don't need a loop to see them. At the time when the crystal blew, the AD called me a month later
to give a quote for the crystal and a new dial($2,500 btw).
We sent the 5960 back, still waiting.
Since last september, I wore my 5960 for 2 weeks now.


More posts: 510159605980complicationsgrand complicationsnautilus

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

What happened to me!

 
 By: Vilit : May 26th, 2009-01:00
Am I an unlucky person? :-( I bought 5980 in June last year. Wearing it for one week and then this sxxt happened. My AD sent it to fix in Singapore for two weeks. The watch came back fine, but nearly two weeks wearing this sxxt happened again. This time i...  

Wow this is one unlucky story

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : May 26th, 2009-01:14
There are few solutions a) if you love the piece very very much ask for third one as they say third time luck b) if you are sick with PP ask money back or c) new piece + big discount All the best Damian

Unbelievable....

 
 By: Rob : May 26th, 2009-01:56
sorry to hear that. Have heard of at least 4 other stories of this but not happening to the same person over and over. Hope this gets resolved once and for all soon enough...

that does not....

 
 By: MiniCooper : May 26th, 2009-04:32
say much about PP quality Is it the only model or are there are ones that have similar problems? cheers

you have answered to yourself...

 
 By: kkhazen : May 26th, 2009-08:13
... if ur love for Patek went down to Zero, in that case, try to get a refund, or sell it back, or jst trade it for something else. Simple... Even if its a gr8 watch, and this could to you with any other brand. I have a Lange timezone, that had the hands ... 

You have been very unlucky.

 
 By: ling5hk : May 26th, 2009-15:38
You should ask for a third watch from your AD and let PP "slowly" get their watches repaired provided always that you still like PP. Regards Ling

Patek Seal

 
 By: NJ : May 26th, 2009-15:58
Perhaps the new Patek Seal really does stand for something entirely new: sloppy workmanship !

One word ...

 
 By: nothing but time : May 26th, 2009-18:55
Lemania

5980 doesn't suit you

 
 By: janut : May 26th, 2009-19:01
I think 5970 suit you better ..

my sympathy is with you,

 
 By: dreamer : May 26th, 2009-19:28
But it just lends support to my view that PP sporty watches are fragile, but then again. you could be very unlucky.

Yikes!

 
 By: Mostel : May 26th, 2009-19:30
I read about a similar story about a year ago... obviously a QC oversight. Good luck. So sorry to hear about it.

I was sorry to read your thread...........

 
 By: Topcat30093 : May 26th, 2009-22:34
I hope that you get things resolved one way or another and to your satisfaction soon.

I feel very sad for you, Vilit

 
 By: amanico : May 26th, 2009-23:01
Well, there are some watches you know you will meet problems with, like, for instance, the U.N Freak 1.O. While knowing that, you know you have ot be patient, in case of problem(s). But when you buy a watch from a Manufacture who claims Excellence as a Fi... 

I'm sorry for you!

 
 By: Dje : May 27th, 2009-03:43
Hi, I'm saddened by your story like everybody here! Just amazing! What is (still positively) surprising is that we don't hear so often such stories! It seems that there problems but not that many! Please let us informed about the following! Cheers Dje

I would try...

 
 By: mac_omega : May 29th, 2009-12:06
Hi Vilit, forget the so called "sporty watches" from Patek - take a vintage one and you will be happy with Patek for the rest of your life   I have an "antimagnetic"  from the 60ies and it keeps time within one second per day! kind regards Erich

I am THEE unlucky one!!!

 
 By: SimplyComplicated : June 2nd, 2009-18:26
First I will "copy/paste" of what happened to me since last september, which I posted before. Post #1 Dated November 2008 "I truly put a lot of thought before posting the following. But I think I should share. Few weeks ago, I posted a message talking abo... 

truly bad luck...

 
 By: MiniCooper : June 2nd, 2009-19:33
I feel for you I hope that all is well now Cheers