nonsense

Jun 17, 2011,07:17 AM
 

This particular criticism of the mini-rotor is nonsensical and uninformed. firstly, separate the issue of efficiency of wind from power: once the rotor powers the spring, its job is done. If you're worried about the ability of the watch powering complications, you should be discussing the power transmission issues from the spring onward not the rotor. Secondly, the mini rotor system runs far more complicated watches such as ref 5074 and 5013 without any problems.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Hugh ??? Did I completely miss this one or they they keep a good secret

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : June 9th, 2011-11:52
Most of the times we know which new watches will be made. Or at least we get info on forums like these Now, this one ?? A 5235 white gold annual calendar regulator ---- never seen or even heard of it untill half an hour ago This was in the new Patek magaz...  

Interesting - news to me

 
 By: Nomer : June 9th, 2011-13:12
I've not heard of this watch nor have I received my magazine! Not immediately attractive to me (personally averse to off-center labels) but like much with Patek, it needs to be seen in person no doubt. best, Hugh

strange, a NEW reference - a very different Patek

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : June 9th, 2011-14:00
and nothing, , really nothing on any forum ? Google "patek 5235" and you'll get ZERO results , did I get a wrong magzaine LOL

Movement

 
 By: aaronm : June 9th, 2011-15:34
Originally I thought it was just a recut 240, with different bridges, but although the overall layout is close, the wheels don't appear to line-up. Very unusual if Patek has decided "meh, we won't bother promoting an entirely new watch/caliber" A

I quote the magazine

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : June 9th, 2011-22:07
Genesis of a new movement Patek Philippe has a iverse portfolio of manufacture calibers.However, none of them perfectly duited the annual calendar regulator ref 5235, and do the companu neede to develop a new movement. The tesult is reminiscent in many re... 

Not receive the meg yet, but, is that a joke ...........

 
 By: JamesWirral : June 10th, 2011-07:25
with a height of <2.6mm? Astonishing!

The movement is that thin.. not the whole watch

 
 By: Mostel : June 10th, 2011-13:17
is what I think the article says... anyway... I think its pretty cool....but I don't like one-handed watches.... in terms of ownership... but design-wise, pretty cool.

Don't love it so far...

 
 By: patrick_y : June 9th, 2011-16:33
Interesting new movement. I always liked micro-rotor automatics so I'm finding that I'm actually staring at the picture of the new movement rather than the pictures of the dial. But I rarely like regulators and this one is not particularly appeasing to my... 

wow--an intriguing piece! [nt]

 
 By: playtime : June 9th, 2011-18:32
No message body

News to me

 
 By: Davo : June 9th, 2011-21:28
And I like it... a lot! Thanks for the scoop.

Interesting

 
 By: Dje : June 10th, 2011-05:58
Hi, Thank you for the info. I've not heard of it. I've heard that there's a Patek Philippe press conference soon but I'm not invited. Maybe that's the reason..... Cheers Dje

I cant't believe

 
 By: lanzet : June 10th, 2011-07:03
Very interesting ... but so far away from PP. I assume it to be a good joke.

The 22nd it seems to be!

 
 By: Georg : June 16th, 2011-07:46
My retailer told me, the 5235 will be presented on the 22nd and he got me a first (and probably not exact) estimate on the price, which will be around SFR 44.000.

Today is the 22nd :-)

 
 By: Georg : June 22nd, 2011-06:56
so I am very much looking forward to any news from the press conference! So, Imran, I take your post here as a promise, so please type quickly ;-) Best regards Georg

Sector dial

 
 By: watch-er : June 10th, 2011-12:34
I am not a big fan of the sector dials on the new larger watches. But I will have to it in the flesh to really know.

NiceDial

 
 By: Timertom : June 10th, 2011-13:37
Thats a nice looking dial, but the hands are really not to my taste. Surely PP could have come up with something more elegant for such a beautiful dial. Rishad

Interesting piece...I'd like it a 24 hour dial (12 high).

 
 By: =RWK= : June 10th, 2011-15:12
Thanks, Bruno! -- Richard. This message has been edited by =RWK= on 2011-06-10 15:17:58

Interesting new calibre...

 
 By: twom4 : June 10th, 2011-23:37
... not sure about the dial and single arms design.

new annual calendar 5235

 
 By: porter505 : June 12th, 2011-08:07
with new calibre which i was told it should be announced in Basel this yr but it doesnt show up. should be later of this yr or next yr.

Not even my retailer knew

 
 By: Georg : June 14th, 2011-03:01
Just got my copy of the Patek-Mag (German edition seems a bit late) and fell immediately in love with the new 5235. So I picked up the phone to call my patek-dealer and was surprised, that they have never heard of that watch. It is probably too early to a... 

I would be concerned..

 
 By: jimjenkins : June 14th, 2011-22:17
to wear this watch. It has a mini rotor, notorious for its less than desirable efficiency to wind. There are many stories out in the cyberspace regarding winding inefficiencies of similarly powered 240 calibers. Therefore, I would be concerned that this l... 

They enlarged the mini-rotor

 
 By: Georg : June 15th, 2011-00:07
"The movement is now 2,60mm high (0,07mm higher than the original 240), because the went for a thicker and therefore heavier rotor, which increases his ability to power the movement." That is, what the PP-Mag states in the german edition. Please excuse my... 

240 winding efficiency

 
 By: enjoythemusic : June 15th, 2011-04:40
Had a Patek World Time for years (240 mvt) and it wound fine.

mini rotor no problem

 
 By: tomch : June 16th, 2011-02:44
I have a 3940 with mini rotor and it runs perfectly. I find this mini rotor very attractive. It is a well working solution that is different. Differentiation is what I am looking for. Thomas...  

Mini-rotor works fine with my 5712 ...

 
 By: Georg : June 16th, 2011-07:30
... since 2008....  

Actually, the PC 5140 houses the Cal 240...

 
 By: amanico : June 16th, 2011-07:58
So, I guess PP trust in their movement... Best, Nicolas.

Cal. 240

 
 By: olan : June 22nd, 2011-07:53
... and so the Ref. 3940 did (since 1987), though it is moving a perpetual calender also. My Ref. 6000 houses a Cal. 240 also - up to now there weren't any problems. Oliver

nonsense

 
 By: amajidi1 : June 17th, 2011-07:17
This particular criticism of the mini-rotor is nonsensical and uninformed. firstly, separate the issue of efficiency of wind from power: once the rotor powers the spring, its job is done. If you're worried about the ability of the watch powering complicat... 

So far it looks ...

 
 By: small-luxury-world : June 20th, 2011-05:09
very nice, but has to be seen in the metal and on the/my wrist There is an official presentation soon, the estimated price is sfr. 44K, available at the end of the year ... Personal thought: If the price is correct, this is one of the few "moderate" price...