not my cup of tea

May 25, 2011,05:55 AM
 

and the price is insane, more than 5712/1A  lol

Locked login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

I heard several opposite comments about the 5164A

 
 By: foversta : May 23rd, 2011-13:52
Some appreciate the beauty of its dial and the clever integration of a useful complication. Others regret the shape of the two pushers on the left and a too busy dial for an Aquanaut. What is your point of view about this watch ? Hot or not ? Thanks for y...  

Tortured, compared to the " simple " original.

 
 By: amanico : May 23rd, 2011-13:55
Less is more, and beautiful. But it is just my opinion.

Sadly I must agree

 
 By: aaronm : May 23rd, 2011-14:09
I don't actually like the regular Aqua, and I find this one too busy in comparison A

+1 !

 
 By: dirost : March 3rd, 2012-07:21
The basic Aquanaut is OK, coherent. This one, with the 2 pushers, seems trying to get closer to the Nautilus ;-)) (by far) The layout of the dial is complicated too, tortured, as Nico said... Not for me. My 2 cents opinion...

not

 
 By: doublesix : May 23rd, 2011-13:56

Not.

 
 By: whit : May 23rd, 2011-14:22

Not! [nt]

 
 By: heartbreaker : May 23rd, 2011-14:24
No message body

in real its better than in pics, but at £20+, that is the problem

 
 By: Miranda : May 23rd, 2011-14:49
this should be a £12-14K piece in my opinion. then...hot now.......luke warm. Best Imran

agree 100% !

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : May 24th, 2011-01:50
I like the watch, don't love it but like it But almost 27.000 euro ??? for a steel watch with 2 timezones on a rubber strap ?? Are they nuts !!!!

Hot

 
 By: Nomer : May 23rd, 2011-16:59
I am not a fan of the Aquanaut nor the traditional modern Patek travel-time watches but this model made me took notice when I first saw it. I think the travel time was a bit too formal for a travel "tool" watch while the Aquanaut itself did not appeal on ... 

It looks overcluttered

 
 By: Frederick : May 23rd, 2011-17:39
All the long minute markers and the wide clunky hands make the face look too busy. Not simple and elegant like the previous models. But then, its just my .02 worth.

I find the pushers to be well integrated into the whole, but the dial

 
 By: playtime : May 23rd, 2011-17:51
suffers, in my opinion, because of the pattern carved into it. They needlessly distract, to my eye. j

Hot

 
 By: Le Chef : May 23rd, 2011-18:28
I want one. to a point that i will sell a couple of my watches, including my 5167, to get one. I own a Rolex GMT IIC and it's an infinitely flashier watch for traveling than the 5164.

the date display a problem

 
 By: ivanclai : May 23rd, 2011-19:26
Actually I have a 5167 and I like it very much for casual wear, simple and elegant, so thin that you dont feel its there. For the 5164, I like the 2 pushers on the left, it matches to the crown guard on the right. The let down is the date display, a simpl... 

Not Hot IMHO

 
 By: dreamer8 : May 23rd, 2011-20:29
all the cutouts spoils the dial.

A big NOT I'm afraid [nt]

 
 By: paulus : May 24th, 2011-01:18
No message body

on a bracelet it would be perfect

 
 By: johnswatch1 : May 24th, 2011-02:13
I really like the travel time complication but the rubber strap is a turn off for me at this price. A few months ago I had a business meeting and the guy opposite me was wearing an aquanaut on a rubber strap. It really clashed badly with the smart busines... 

well ,

 
 By: simplicity : May 24th, 2011-02:38
as often with Patek , looking at the pics : not my cup of tea , when in the flesh : cherry on the cake (maybe) if you see what i mean

And on a Nato? :)))

 
 By: amanico : May 24th, 2011-02:39

yeahhh ! Nicolas

 
 By: simplicity : May 24th, 2011-02:47
some would be GREAT ! LOL www.servimg.com " target="_blank" > " border="0" alt="Image hébergée par servimg.com" />...  

It's twice an Aquanaut in many ways: the Aquanaut as it should be...

 
 By: COUNT DE MONET : May 24th, 2011-05:25
At first, on the photo shop pictures in particular, it looked odd, to put it mildly. With the first real pictures it showed itself: it is truely a double Aquanaut. Firstly it comes with asecond "sub-globe" dial which is the little globe of the pointer dat... 

Just my opinion, but it is one of my least favourite

 
 By: emcquillan : May 24th, 2011-11:23
offerings from Patek Philippe. The dial looks busy and confused.

Thanks a lot for your comments !

 
 By: foversta : May 24th, 2011-12:28
At the end, it seems that you are more disappointed than convinced by this watch. I feel the same. Even if it is quite clever, I found the two night/day indicators very confusing. The pushers, even if they are quite well integrated, breaks the harmony of ... 

Its nice but........

 
 By: TonyR : May 24th, 2011-14:54
there are so many other pieces that I'd rather have within that price range. Tony

50/50 FX

 
 By: =RWK= : May 24th, 2011-23:44
I like the large date wheel, but not the skeleton hour hand. And as others have pointed out the price!??? Cheers, -- Richard.

not my cup of tea

 
 By: porter505 : May 25th, 2011-05:55
and the price is insane, more than 5712/1A lol

Great watch, Im in love ....

 
 By: chronoman19 : May 26th, 2011-11:40

Never been a fan of aquanaut, still not convinced with the 5164

 
 By: Hororgasm : May 27th, 2011-16:28
Sorry, looks contrived and trying too hard...where is the simple elegance or sophisticated presence or moneyed look or technical tour de force? Best, Horo

most definitely not hot

 
 By: Mostel : May 27th, 2011-20:26
Busy and cluttered and very 'we have to come up with something' looking.... but then the original never did much for me either... this one is just transparently lacking all inspiration...

Hot

 
 By: nitediver : May 29th, 2011-03:42
Nice integration of the pushers and a useful function in a practical watch. In short, a good addition to the PP range. I agree with the previous comments that a date window would have the better choice to keep the dial clean. Price? Too high for an aquana... 

question for those who dont like this

 
 By: jasper435 : June 2nd, 2011-12:08
Have you seen one in person? probably not. Otherwise you would like it and thinking the 5167 is better than this

Absolutely hot

 
 By: pjbseattle : June 4th, 2011-18:43
This is the kind of Aquanaut I've been waiting to see.

5164

 
 By: pjbseattle : June 7th, 2011-21:32
do you know if it will come with the bracelet? I'd like to see that.

5164

 
 By: pjbseattle : July 9th, 2011-07:29
Do you know if the date automatically adjusts to the local time? I think this watch is perfect for me since I'm always traveling. It's practical and classy; and seems to be comfortable in any climate. Plus, it doesn't screem flash--a feature that I like w... 

Nice watch.

 
 By: Grisar : July 10th, 2011-09:24
I luckily tried this watch last week. It turned out to be a very nice one and looked much much better than in pictures. I think that 27K EUR is a little bit too much. In this price range, I'd go for a 5712/1A.

I got one today

 
 By: palmbeachguy : February 21st, 2012-16:08
I picked up my 5164a today and I am very pleased. I can give my 5980 a little rest for the moment.

Congratulations! I can't wait to be able to say the same.

 
 By: pjbseattle : February 21st, 2012-16:53
Send some pics.

Here you go, this was before and after the fitting...

 
 By: palmbeachguy : February 21st, 2012-19:15
A look under the hood Old reliable The inspection Before the band cutting/sizing Hmmm, fits perfect!...  

That is a gorgeous Aquanaut and Nautilus

 
 By: pjbseattle : February 22nd, 2012-08:44
You are a very fortunate man to have such beautiful pieces. I really like the Aquanaut 5164; it's perfect for my lifestyle. Thanks for the pics. Ejoy!

Not

 
 By: QuailRider43 : February 22nd, 2012-20:15
I may be a bit biased. I think the entire Nautilus and Aquanaut lines are horribly dated, but I'm a watch newb, so maybe they will grow on me in time. As to your particular question, I find the dial too busy.

Not a fashion brand...

 
 By: pjbseattle : February 23rd, 2012-08:53
The thing to remember about Patek watches is that they don't follow fashing trends--they are classic timepieces that are impervious to fads.

I considered this but

 
 By: Puffy : March 3rd, 2012-05:00
found the dial far too busy and cluttered. i went 5167 and haven't looked back

Cluttered

 
 By: Mostel : March 3rd, 2012-10:45
and 100% un-Patek-like... you can almost hear 'the meeting' where bean counters said 'we've got to adda complication to the Aquanaut." Then you can almost see the committee trying to jam some complications in there, and the sighing designer (s)... and fin... 

I agree with some of your points, Mostel

 
 By: Puffy : March 4th, 2012-03:05
The dial is definitely cluttered and pushers seem like an afterthought.. But I wouldn't refer to the Aquanaut as 'meh'.... less is more, and the Aquanaut is a stunning timepiece. Very well-balanced and it all works in harmony

cluttered, I think not.

 
 By: palmbeachguy : March 4th, 2012-06:03
Here is a picture of my watch, while I am at home and not using the GMT function. Compared to the 5167, or any simple straight time watch, one would suggest that there is a lot going on. As far as the pushers go, it makes setting other time zones lightnin...  

I concur [nt]

 
 By: pjbseattle : March 4th, 2012-18:58
No message body

those pushers..

 
 By: Delamere : March 4th, 2012-01:38
I actually like it, except for the shape of the pushers on the left. They just don't work well with the case. And for that sort of money I would've expected a more impressive looking movement.

For the many of you who don't like any of the Aquanauts...

 
 By: pjbseattle : March 4th, 2012-19:09
Did you ever ask yourself why it is such a smashing success? Plaese tell me.

ugly

 
 By: edwardwchang : March 4th, 2012-21:10
this watch is so ugly that it makes the nautilus look beautiful in comparison, which itself is so ugly that it makes the royal oak look like a piece of good design. Its like Stern wrote a memo to Patek's designers "we have enough watches to capture the cl... 

Kudos Edward !

 
 By: PARK PLAZA : March 4th, 2012-22:42
For speaking the truth for the first time... I am a little tired of blind love people have.... esp on this forum I guess being a ''family company'' has its limitations. Creativity is really low frankly and colour combinations of dial versus watch metal le... 

Ugly??? This is going to get ugly....

 
 By: palmbeachguy : March 5th, 2012-06:45
Now Edward, I am going to apologize now because this is going to hurt a little. Since I am the only person on this thread who actually owns this watch, I take offense to your characterizations of those who own the 5164a. After about 30 seconds of due dili... 

ad hominem

 
 By: edwardwchang : March 5th, 2012-07:24
Dear Sir, Is that you Dr. Freud? I thought we had doctor/patient confidentiality! Unfortunately, your aquanaut still looks like the bastard spawn of a drunken nautilus's one night stand with a cheap casio g-shock. I am excited about the forged carbon roya... 

Who's on first?

 
 By: LwC : March 6th, 2012-08:36
Two men meet at a cocktail party. Amid furtive glances at each other's wrists, they discover that they share an interest in high end watches. One of the men, thinking that the other man is a sophisticated and refined character, proudly shows his newest ac... 

fisticuffs

 
 By: edwardwchang : March 7th, 2012-00:07
This scenario could never happen! No one who wears a fine Patek, even an aquanaut, would get in a fistfight while wearing it! Id rather block a punch with my face than with my left arm with a Patek on the wrist, even the dubious aquanaut GMT. Needless to ... 

Don't waste your sweat...

 
 By: Enriguf : March 6th, 2012-19:36
This guy is obviously delusional and/or a pathological liar and a hypocrite, just look at his past posts, he's making a complete idiot of himself!

ban or warning

 
 By: edwardwchang : March 7th, 2012-00:01
Dear Moderators, The above post by Enriguf has no horological information or value or any content related to watches or watchmaking. The only "content" of the post are personal insults without basis in fact, insults that are also unrelated to horology or ... 

Ok, let me expound..

 
 By: Enriguf : March 7th, 2012-00:21
... my dear Edward. You blatantly insult people without remorse (for no good reason, in fact I'm almost certain you're just a troll), try to portray this sort of "watch snob" persona, all the while spreading your elitist, classist opinion all over the for... 

young

 
 By: edwardwchang : March 7th, 2012-00:42
You're very young. That is a statement of fact, not an insult. Watches are marketed, through advertising campaigns in magazines, product placements in movies, endorsements by celebrities, placement of stores, the type of staff hired at boutiques and how t... 

Please do not play the moderator's role. And since you ignored my request...

 
 By: amanico : March 7th, 2012-01:43
I will lock this thread. Not the best, Nicolas This message has been edited by amanico on 2012-03-07 01:44:02

I am not a huge fan of this reference and frankly

 
 By: whit : March 5th, 2012-16:29
wasn't a fan of the Aquanaut when it was first launched. I just wasn't attracted to it, wasn't crazy about the dial or the rubber strap, but do know it was a huge seller as it was aimed to younger folks at a price point to allow them to enter into the rat...