why in theory only

May 29, 2009,20:39 PM
 

First, Patek does maintain a list of stolen watches, they just don't share the list with all their Ad's. So are they saying it's OK to bring your stolen watch to one of our Ad's but you had better not send it to HQ?

If you had actually sold the watch, then there would be a paper trail showing some form of sale and the rightful owner would have grounds to have you arrested. You probably also turned this in under a home-owners policy if nothing else, so you have insurance fraud as well. This wouldn't be Patek's probelm, but rather the authorities in that jurisdiction.

When you report such an item as being stolen, quite a bit of information goes into the police report. There are not so many stolen watches of that value floating around, so when the owner brings the watch in for service, he or she would probably have some proof as to how they got the watch if questioned.

If it was simply lost, and reported as stolen, I agree this is more difficult to handle, but watches of this value always have a paper trail. If the new owner states "I found it on the beach." then they would have to show under the jurisdiction they live in, that the watch is now legally belongs to them. Many jurisdictions require a person to make an effort to find the rightful owner, if they followed whatever the local rules were, then they have nothing to worry about.

The reality is that there are two types of owners, those that actually have clear title and those who do not. With a little investigation, I don't think it would be that difficult to discover who really owns the watch.

Take mine for example, I have all the paper work, the reciept, box and so on. Someone else just has a 3940 with no proof to show they obtained it legally.

As I said earlier, it also would sting the grey market a bit.

 


More posts: 3940grand complications

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Stolen watch database- Doesn't exist!!!!

 
 By: Fallanden.ch : May 29th, 2009-18:35
I had a Patek 3940 perpetual stolen in 1996 from my home. I know who took the watch as there was a repair person in the house that day and he had access to the place where my beloved watch was resting. It actually was hidden, but you had to pass through m... 

I think its a good idea too [nt]

 
 By: gazoz : May 29th, 2009-19:24
No message body

Sorry but good idea in theory only

 
 By: autowind : May 29th, 2009-19:37
How does Stern know that your watch was stolen? How do they separate a valid claim from a false claim? I suspect they don't want to be in the business of policing and/or arbitrating whether or not a watch submitted by a customer truly belongs to that cust... 

why in theory only

 
 By: Fallanden.ch : May 29th, 2009-20:39
First, Patek does maintain a list of stolen watches, they just don't share the list with all their Ad's. So are they saying it's OK to bring your stolen watch to one of our Ad's but you had better not send it to HQ? If you had actually sold the watch, the... 

unfortunately

 
 By: autowind : May 29th, 2009-21:19
that's not true. I've purchased watches from ADs, gray market dealers, and individuals from around the world. With the exception of those purchased from ADs, i've almost never known the original owner and often don't have any paperwork. This is particular... 

good point, but then why have the current policy

 
 By: Fallanden.ch : May 29th, 2009-21:42
The current policy is that Patek maintains a database of stolen watches at Henri Stern and in Geneva. As long as you contact both yourself, they don't exchange information. I was told today that if my watch ever were to show up at Stern, it would be froze... 

You have my sympathy and I agree with you.

 
 By: dreamer : May 30th, 2009-04:55
There should be closer cooperation with maintaining a central database.Also , with respect to those who argues that if you bought a watch in good faith and subsequently the watch was found/proven to have been stolen, it rightly belongs to that person.The ... 

police report

 
 By: whit : June 1st, 2009-10:55
Simply filing the police report is not sufficient, you need to send a copy of the report to Stern or to Geneva. My understanding is that nothing can be done without it. To be on the safe side, contact Patek and ask what they require.

I think....

 
 By: MiniCooper : May 30th, 2009-05:55
that some middle ground should be found You have my complete understanding and sympathies- I would be equally frustrated if one of my watches was stolen. The AD should participate more- they should have an updated list of (proven) stolen watches. but also... 

stolen 3940

 
 By: whit : May 30th, 2009-07:55
I am somewhat familiar with your situation. A client of mine had his watch stolen from his hotel room in SC while on vacation, he called me to let me know and I informed H. Stern. Ten or twelve years later, I get a call from Stern, the watch had come in f... 

yes, I forgot to mention making a police report

 
 By: dreamer : June 1st, 2009-01:06
Make a police report within a short reasonable period after it has been stolen.Police will ask many questions and verify you docs.etc, where you originally bought it from etc.This is fairly standard practice for insurance claims as well, with insurance co... 

Do you remember the case in

 
 By: Sonny : May 30th, 2009-21:22
Singapore a few months ago when a big AD salesman stole watches worth millions? He ran to Thailand and surrender himself later in the Singapore Embassy. I was wondering why he surrender? The chance of the interpol to find him in Thailand and many developi... 

Teriffic idea..

 
 By: nothing but time : May 31st, 2009-05:50
They should add it here in beta as a tab, like with the collector market.

Stolen Watch

 
 By: Fallanden.ch : June 1st, 2009-12:15
Thank those of you who properly understand what it must feel like to have a 3940 stolen from your home, only to find out that Patek really does nothing to help return the watch to you. Again, any complicated Patek at some point in it's life wil need the s...